Skip to main content

Main menu

  • Home
  • Content
    • Published Ahead of Print
    • Current Issue
    • Podcasts
    • Subject Collections
    • Archives
    • Kidney Week Abstracts
    • Saved Searches
  • Authors
    • Submit a Manuscript
    • Author Resources
  • Trainees
    • Peer Review Program
    • Prize Competition
  • About CJASN
    • About CJASN
    • Editorial Team
    • CJASN Impact
    • CJASN Recognitions
  • More
    • Alerts
    • Advertising
    • Feedback
    • Reprint Information
    • Subscriptions
  • ASN Kidney News
  • Other
    • ASN Publications
    • JASN
    • Kidney360
    • Kidney News Online
    • American Society of Nephrology

User menu

  • Subscribe
  • My alerts
  • Log in
  • My Cart

Search

  • Advanced search
American Society of Nephrology
  • Other
    • ASN Publications
    • JASN
    • Kidney360
    • Kidney News Online
    • American Society of Nephrology
  • Subscribe
  • My alerts
  • Log in
  • My Cart
Advertisement
American Society of Nephrology

Advanced Search

  • Home
  • Content
    • Published Ahead of Print
    • Current Issue
    • Podcasts
    • Subject Collections
    • Archives
    • Kidney Week Abstracts
    • Saved Searches
  • Authors
    • Submit a Manuscript
    • Author Resources
  • Trainees
    • Peer Review Program
    • Prize Competition
  • About CJASN
    • About CJASN
    • Editorial Team
    • CJASN Impact
    • CJASN Recognitions
  • More
    • Alerts
    • Advertising
    • Feedback
    • Reprint Information
    • Subscriptions
  • ASN Kidney News
  • Visit ASN on Facebook
  • Follow CJASN on Twitter
  • CJASN RSS
  • Community Forum
Editorials
You have accessRestricted Access

The Hazards of Transplant Tourism

Francis L. Delmonico
CJASN February 2009, 4 (2) 249-250; DOI: https://doi.org/10.2215/CJN.05801108
Francis L. Delmonico
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • Article
  • Info & Metrics
  • View PDF
Loading

In the November issue of the CJASN, Jagbir Gill et al. present a University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) series of 33 patients that underwent kidney transplantation in a foreign country and returned to the United States for post-transplant care. “Transplant tourists” are traveling to established destinations to obtain readily accessible organs for transplantation, available from the poor of that destination country who sell mostly kidneys, but in some instances, a lobe of the liver or a cornea. These practices have been well known for more than a decade. In 2004, the World Health Assembly (WHA) issued a resolution urging member states “to take measures to protect the poorest and vulnerable groups from transplant tourism and the sale of tissues and organs, including attention to the wider problem of international trafficking in human tissues and organs.”

Although the WHA 2004 resolution was unambiguous in its objection to trafficking and transplant tourism, a comprehensive description of these unethical practices was still needed. To address the concerns of the WHA, a Summit Meeting of more than 150 international representatives of scientific and medical bodies, government officials, social scientists, and ethicists was held in Istanbul, Turkey from April 30 to May 2, 2008. The result of these deliberations was the Istanbul Declaration on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism.

Gill describes the transplant tourist as a resident of the United States who underwent transplantation outside the United States and then returned for follow-up care. The UCLA group makes no conclusion regarding the ethical propriety of this practice, disclaiming social circumstances that may have propelled these patients to travel for transplantation. The Istanbul Declaration, however, distinguishes travel for transplantation from transplant tourism by means of the following: “travel for transplantation is the movement of organs, donors, recipients or transplant professionals across jurisdictional borders for transplantation purposes. Travel for transplantation becomes transplant tourism if it involves organ trafficking and/or transplant commercialism or if the resources (organs, professionals and transplant centers) devoted to providing transplants to patients from outside a country undermine the country's ability to provide transplant services for its own population.” The practical basis for concern arises when the destination country places its own resident patient population at disadvantage for gaining access to the list because lucrative arrangements for patients from the client countries simultaneously claim an allocation priority. Meanwhile, in the client country, readily available access to organs (in the destination country) prevents deceased-donor programs from gaining widespread support.

Nevertheless, not all recipient travel for transplantation in a foreign country is unethical. The Istanbul Declaration provides additional guidance that travel for transplantation may be ethical if the following conditions are fulfilled:

For Live Donors

if the recipient has a dual citizenship and wishes to undergo transplantation from a live donor that is a family member in a country of citizenship that is not their residence;

if the donor and recipient are genetically related and wish to undergo transplantation in a country not of their residence.

For Deceased Donors

if official regulated bilateral or multilateral organ sharing programs based on a reciprocated organ sharing programs exist between or among countries or jurisdictions .

Gill reports that 17 (52%) of the 33 UCLA tourist patients had infections, with nine requiring hospitalization. The 1-year graft survival was 89% for tourists and 98% for the matched UCLA cohort. The comparative outcome of the tourist patients is a compelling revelation of the hazards of undergoing transplantation in a foreign country. These data are important to transplant physicians who advise their patients not to undertake such risks without some acceptance of the fate that comes with an unpredictable transplant experience. Donor transmitted infection may not be surprising if the kidney is obtained from an executed prisoner in China, where tuberculosis and hepatitis are more prevalent, rather than a deceased donor in the United States.

Notwithstanding these UCLA data, the transplant physician ultimately has to care for the transplant tourist, despite the appropriate admonition to such a patient. The transplant physician has an obligation to care for patients and not judge them. Nevertheless, the Israeli Ministry of Health has recently developed a more practical approach: if it is illegal to undergo transplantation in a foreign country (for example, now in the Philippines), then insurance companies should not condone or provide support for such an illegal activity. This approach would not solve the conundrum of care for the physician, but it would be a substantial deterrent for transplant tourists who seek to undergo the procedure in a foreign country.

The UCLA data and the Istanbul Declaration represent a concerted effort to establish a national self-sufficiency in every country with transplantation practices. Client countries should no longer presume that donor organs from the poor will be preferentially available to their rich patient population because of their affluence and ability to travel. The data from this UCLA report should also be a stark reminder that transplantation care requires an expertise best provided by a transplant center that is devoted to the patient's interest, not to the patient's resources.

Footnotes

  • Published online ahead of print. Publication date available at www.cjasn.org.

  • See related article, “Transplant Tourism in the United States: A Single-Center Experience,” on pages 1820–1828 of the November 2008 issue of CJASN.

  • Copyright © 2009 by the American Society of Nephrology
PreviousNext
Back to top

In this issue

Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology
Vol. 4, Issue 2
February 2009
  • Table of Contents
  • Table of Contents (PDF)
  • Index by author
View Selected Citations (0)
Print
Download PDF
Sign up for Alerts
Email Article
Thank you for your help in sharing the high-quality science in CJASN.
Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
The Hazards of Transplant Tourism
(Your Name) has sent you a message from American Society of Nephrology
(Your Name) thought you would like to see the American Society of Nephrology web site.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Citation Tools
The Hazards of Transplant Tourism
Francis L. Delmonico
CJASN Feb 2009, 4 (2) 249-250; DOI: 10.2215/CJN.05801108

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero
Request Permissions
Share
The Hazards of Transplant Tourism
Francis L. Delmonico
CJASN Feb 2009, 4 (2) 249-250; DOI: 10.2215/CJN.05801108
del.icio.us logo Digg logo Reddit logo Twitter logo Facebook logo Google logo Mendeley logo
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like

Jump to section

  • Article
    • For Live Donors
    • For Deceased Donors
    • Footnotes
  • Info & Metrics
  • View PDF

More in this TOC Section

  • Telehealth and Kidney Disease Care
  • Time to Abandon Kidney Biopsy to Diagnose Membranous Nephropathy?
  • Should We Let Dialysis Patients Eat Their Fruits and Veggies?
Show more Editorials

Cited By...

  • No citing articles found.
  • Google Scholar

Similar Articles

Related Articles

  • Transplant Tourism in the United States: A Single-Center Experience
  • PubMed
  • Google Scholar

Articles

  • Current Issue
  • Early Access
  • Subject Collections
  • Article Archive
  • ASN Meeting Abstracts

Information for Authors

  • Submit a Manuscript
  • Trainee of the Year
  • Author Resources
  • ASN Journal Policies
  • Reuse/Reprint Policy

About

  • CJASN
  • ASN
  • ASN Journals
  • ASN Kidney News

Journal Information

  • About CJASN
  • CJASN Email Alerts
  • CJASN Key Impact Information
  • CJASN Podcasts
  • CJASN RSS Feeds
  • Editorial Board

More Information

  • Advertise
  • ASN Podcasts
  • ASN Publications
  • Become an ASN Member
  • Feedback
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Password/Email Address Changes
  • Subscribe to ASN Journals

© 2022 American Society of Nephrology

Print ISSN - 1555-9041 Online ISSN - 1555-905X

Powered by HighWire