|
|
||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Dialysis |



,||
,||
* Division of Geriatric Medicine, Faculty of Medicine,
Department of Health Care and Epidemiology, and ¶ Centre for Clinical Epidemiology and Evaluation, Vancouver Coastal Health Research Institute, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia,
Division of Clinical Decision-making & Health Care, Toronto General Research Institute, and Departments of
Ophthalmology and || Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Address correspondence to: Dr. Sarbjit V. Jassal, University of Toronto and Staff Physician, University Health Network, 8NU-857, 200 Elizabeth Street, Toronto, M5G 2C4, Canada. Phone: 416-340-3196; Fax: 416-340-4999; E-mail: vanita.jassal{at}uhn.on.ca
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
65 yr) chronic outpatient hemodialysis (HD) patients would be higher than published rates for community-dwelling seniors (0.6 to 0.8 falls/patient-year). It also was hypothesized that risk factors for falls in dialysis outpatients would include polypharmacy, dialysis-related hypotension, cognitive impairment, and decreased functional status. Using a prospective cohort study design, HD patients who were
65 yr of age at a large academic dialysis unit were recruited. All study participants underwent baseline screening for fall risk factors. Patients were followed prospectively for a minimum of 1 yr. Falls were identified through biweekly patient interviews in the HD unit. A total of 162 patients (mean age 74.7 yr) were recruited; 57% were male. A total of 305 falls occurred in 76 (47%) patients over 190.5 person-years of follow-up (fall-incidence 1.60 falls/person-year). Injuries occurred in 19% of falls; 41 patients had multiple falls. Associated risk factors included age, comorbidity, mean predialysis systolic BP, and a history of falls. In the HD population, the fall risk is higher than in the general community, and fall-related morbidity is high. Better identification of HD patients who are at risk for falls and targeted fall intervention strategies are required. | Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Falls are a major problem in older people. More than 30% of community dwellers who are older than 65 yr fall at least once during a 1-yr period, with a higher incidence of falls being common in frail individuals or those with disabilities (36). Falls are the most common cause of trauma in the elderly, with unintentional injuries being the ninth most common cause of death in this age group (7). A fall can be the first manifestation of serious or acute physical decline (8). Falls predict hospitalization, functional decline, and the need for long-term institutional care (911). Even in the absence of physical injury, falls can lead to the individual becoming fearful of experiencing subsequent falls (12). In turn, this fear of falling syndrome often causes a voluntary limitation of mobility, a gradual decrease in functional independence, and ultimately an increased need for residential care (13). Therefore, the health implications of falls are enormous, with costs for fall-related fractures alone being estimated at well over US$10 billion (14).
Falls among dialysis patients have received little attention. Previous reports of falls in the dialysis population are limited to a few retrospective or short-term prospective studies (1517). These suggest that the prevalence of falls in the elderly hemodialysis (HD) population is at least as high as in individuals without uremia in the community (16,17) and that the incidence of fall events may be higher (15). No long-term prospective studies have been reported in this population to determine accurately the annual incidence of falls or to examine the risk factors for falls.
Numerous risk factors for falls in older people have been identified, many of which are amenable to intervention (3). Problems that are associated with increased fall risk include arthritis, depressive symptoms, and orthostasis, as well as impairment in cognition, vision, balance, strength, and gait (3,18). The use of more than four prescription medications of any type increases fall risk (18). Specific culprit medications include sedatives, tricyclic antidepressants, anticonvulsants, or class 1A anti-arrhythmics and drugs that predispose to hypotension (19,20). Patients with a past history of falls are at an increased risk for recurrent nonsyncopal falls (21).
Older dialysis patients tend to have numerous risk factors for falls. They often have multiple comorbidities at the time of starting dialysis, including a high prevalence of diabetes, cardiovascular disease, depression, sleep disorders, restless leg syndrome, and peripheral and autonomic neuropathies (22,23). Polypharmacy is ubiquitous in dialysis patients. Furthermore, HD is associated with rapid fluid and electrolyte shifts that predispose patients to dialysis-related hypotension and self-limiting arrhythmias (24). Combined, these risk factors could place older dialysis patients at a very high risk for falling. The objectives of this prospective cohort study were to determine the incidence of falls and the proportion of fallers among dialysis patients who are aged
65 yr during at least a 1-yr period, to document the resulting morbidity and mortality, and to identify fall risk factors in this population.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study Participants
The inclusion criteria were (1) age
65 yr and (2) undergoing chronic HD at the University Health Network, Toronto, Canada, during the period April 9, 2002, to April 9, 2003 (both incident and prevalent patients). Patients were excluded when they were unable or unwilling to provide informed consent. Patients who were living in a long-term institutional setting were excluded. Ethics approval was granted by the local Research Ethics Board.
Baseline Assessment
Baseline assessments were conducted by a research nurse using standardized protocols. The medical history was abstracted from clinical and electronic charts. The Charlson Comorbidity Index was used to summarize medical comorbidity (25). A full medication, dialysis, and laboratory history was recorded for each patient. BP and dialysis details of the last six consecutive dialysis sessions were recorded. These included predialysis, postdialysis, and nadir BP during dialysis. The need for saline bolus(es) to maintain BP during dialysis and the mean volume of ultrafiltration also were noted. Medications that are known to predispose to falls, termed fall-provoking medications, were defined as those that potentially result in low BP (ß blockers, calcium-channel blockers, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, angiotensin receptor blockers, any nitrate administered on a regular basis, diuretics, adrenergic and serotoninergic modulators, and vasodilators) and those that potentially cause sedation or impaired cognition (benzodiazepines, antidepressants, antiseizure medications, antihistamines, opiates, and miscellaneous sedative agents). Basic and instrumental activities of daily living were measured using the Barthel (26) and the Lawton-Brody Instrumental Activities of Daily Living Scale (27). Patients were questioned regarding their use of a walking aid.
All patients were asked to participate in a full clinical evaluation that included the following: Assessment of depressive symptoms using the Mental Health Inventory (28); cognitive assessment using the Folstein Mini-Mental Status Examination (29) and clock drawing task (30); assessment of falls, including events recalled from the previous 12 mo, fear of falling (31), and falls efficacy (32); assessment of vision (expressed as the functional acuity score [33]); assessment of hearing (whisper test) (34); assessment for foot abnormalities (examination for ulcers, amputation, or minor deformities, e.g., bunion or toe deformities); and assessment of orthostatic BP and heart rate immediately before dialysis. All patients also were asked to participate in an evaluation of functional mobility as measured by the timed up-and-go (TUG) test (31,35).
Follow-Up
Patients were visited by the research nurse every two weeks to ascertain whether they had fallen. Additional verbal reports of falls from patients or dialysis nursing staff or reports of falls that resulted in admissions were followed up by the research nurse. Details of falls were obtained using a standardized form based on the Frailty and Injuries: Cooperative Studies of Intervention Techniques (FICSIT) studies, which included timing, circumstances, injuries sustained, and any health care attention sought (31). Timing of falls was categorized into "before dialysis on a dialysis day," "after dialysis on a dialysis day," and "on a nondialysis day." Patients were followed until April 9, 2004; death; transfer to another HD unit; or kidney transplantation.
Definition of a Fall
A fall was defined as an event that resulted in a persons coming to rest inadvertently on the ground or other lower level (31). Injurious falls were defined as those that caused minor (e.g., cuts, bruises) or major injuries (e.g., fractures, loss of consciousness, hospitalization, death). For simple comparisons of fallers and nonfallers, patients were considered to be fallers when they sustained one or more falls during the follow-up period.
Statistical Analyses
Demographic data were analyzed using descriptive statistics (mean ± SD, or median and quartiles for continuous data and percentages for categorical data, respectively).
The fall incidence was determined from the number of falls that occurred during the study divided by person-years of follow-up. The average number of falls per individual during the study was determined with the mean cumulative function (MCF; SAS version 9.1; SAS Institute, Cary, NC) (36). The timing of falls with respect to dialysis treatment days was examined by comparison of the average number of falls per person on dialysis days versus nondialysis days using the MCF. Univariate comparisons between fallers and nonfallers were made using the
2 test, t test, or Mantel-Haenszel tests, as appropriate.
The "fall rate" was calculated for each patient by dividing the number of observed falls by the total follow-up time in years. Each patient was classified into one of four ordered categories of numbers of falls per year: (1) zero, (2) more than zero and up to 1, (3) more than 1 and up to 2, and (4) more than 2. A proportional odds regression model was used to relate this ordinal outcome to variables that were hypothesized a priori to predict fall incidence. These predictor variables were history of falls (dichotomous variable); age (per decade); the total number of fall-provoking medications; gender; and comorbidity score, mean predialysis systolic BP (SBP), vision and Mini-Mental Status Examination adjusted for age, education, and gender (37). Interpretation of the odds ratio in the proportional odds model differs from that in standard binary logistic regression models as it indicates how the predictor changes the odds of a patients being in one of the higher fall rate groups as compared with the lower fall rate groups. The overall model fit was assessed through a likelihood ratio test that compared this model with the multinomial model. A significance level of 0.05 was used. Regression and demographic analyses were performed using R-statistical software (version 2,01; R-Core Development Group, R Foundation of Vienna, Vienna, Austria).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Baseline characteristics of those studied are presented in Tables 1
through 3. Fallers were more likely to be older (75.8 versus 73.9 yr; P = 0.04), to have required dialysis for a shorter period of time (2.4 versus 3.4 yr; NS), to have a higher number of comorbid conditions at baseline (11.0 versus 9.8; P = 0.03), and to recall having had one or more falls in the 12 mo before the study.
|
|
|
15s, and those who needed aid/assistance) did not predict falls.
Fall Incidence
Patients were followed for a median of 468 d (quartiles 365 to 506 d). Thirty-eight patients did not complete at least 12 mo of follow-up because of death (n = 27; 71%), transfer to another facility (n = 7; 18%), kidney transplantation (n = 3; 8%), or renal recovery (n = 1). Of those with <12 mo of follow-up, the median period of follow-up was 241 d (quartiles 147 to 304 d). A total of 305 falls occurred among 76 patients during 190.5 person-years of follow-up for a fall incidence rate of 1.60 falls/person-year (Figure 1). Of the 76 patients who fell, 45 (57%) had multiple (two or more) falls (range 2 to 48). After exclusion of one individual with 48 falls, the fall rate was 1.36 falls/person-year. Using the MCF method, the average number of falls per person per year was 2.78 (95% confidence interval [CI] 1.75 to 3.80).
|
Fall-Related Injuries
Injurious falls were common (167 [55%] of 305); however, emergency department visits occurred in only 12.5% of all falls and 24% of all injurious falls. Some patients chose not to visit the emergency department but sought medical attention in the dialysis unit (n = 19), bringing the total proportion of falls that required medical attention to 19%. Most (136 [81%] of 305) injuries were minor (bruises, lacerations, and sprains), but 12 (7%) individuals sustained head injuries with loss of consciousness and eight (4%) sustained fractures of their upper limb (n = 3), hip/pelvis (n = 4), or lower limb (n = 1). Twenty-six (16%) patients were hospitalized as a direct result of the fall. A total of six (4%) patients died within 7 d of their fall as a direct result of the fall-related injury.
Factors That Are Predictive of Falls
The ordinal regression results showed that male gender, a history of falls, low mean predialysis SBP, and higher comorbidity were statistically significant and clinically important risk factors for falls. The relationship between mean predialysis SBP and fall risk is shown in Figure 2. Age increased the odds for having more falls but was not statistically significantly. Vision, cognitive impairment, and the number of medications were not predictive of falls (Table 4). Model fit was good (likelihood ratio
2 = 11.7 on 11 df, P = 0.76).
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
At initial glance, the burden of falls reported in this article seems much higher than in previous reports on dialysis populations; in older, frail populations (0.6 to 0.84 falls/patient-year [6,18]) and in those who reside in nursing facilities (1.0 to 1.4 falls/resident-year [41]). A retrospective study in our own dialysis unit found that only 27% of seniors who were on chronic HD recalled having had a fall within the previous 12 mo (17). In an 8-wk prospective study, Desmet et al. (15) found that only 12.7% of their dialysis population (of all ages) had a fall, and they noted a fall rate of 1.18 falls/person-year. It is very likely that both studies underestimated the fall risk in seniors who were on HD because of study design limitations. Retrospective studies are prone to recall and survivorship biases (42), whereas studies with a short follow-up period have increased measurement error because of the unpredictable timing of falls. Our study likely is more representative of the actual fall risk for older dialysis patients.
Our data are limited by the fact that we recruited dialysis patients from a single in-center HD unit. As with most units within Canada, our unit conforms to Canadian HD practice guidelines (43). We perform regular quality assurance surveys that are based on dialysis adequacy, achieved hemoglobin levels, and bone metabolism parameters (calcium, phosphate, and parathormone levels). By restricting our study population to a singe center, we increased the homogeneity of care provided at the expense of possibly decreasing the generalizability of the results to other units across the world. The second limitation of our study is incomplete physical performance data. Physical performance measures and fall risk have been correlated closely in many studies of falls (5,44). Unfortunately, we found that many of our patients were either unwilling or unable to participate in the TUG test without the use of assistance or an aid, suggesting that dialysis patients have a higher level of disability than previously recognized.
We used biweekly patient interviews to identify falls. Thus, we depended on patients remembering whether they did or did not have a fall and when that fall occurred. Most fall studies track falls prospectively using a fall calendar that is mailed either weekly or monthly in an effort to reduce recall bias. Unlike community-dwelling seniors, HD patients interact with health care staff on average three times per week. In a pilot study within the HD unit, we found that patient participation with fall calendars was poor, with patients preferring to report falls verbally. We reduced errors that were the result of underreporting or misclassification of falls by ensuring that the study nurse formally interviewed each participant biweekly to identify and obtain detailed information about each fall (45). It still is possible that we did not capture some falls and that our data are limited by recall bias, especially given the relatively high prevalence of cognitive impairment in our patient population. If present, then recall bias would result in an underestimation of the fall rate and our high reported fall rate would be a conservative estimate of the true fall rate.
One of our study objectives was to identify risk factors for older dialysis patients who were most likely to fall repeatedly. We found that low predialysis SBP, male gender, increased comorbidity, and a history of falls were predictive of recurrent falls. The relationship between predialysis SBP and falls is not surprising and has been reported in both the geriatric and nephrology literature (16,19). Of importance, BP is the only potentially modifiable risk factor identified, and our data argue in favor of raising predialysis BP targets in older HD patients who report previous falls. The general geriatric literature reports an increased prevalence of falls in individuals who use four or more medications (3,18). We were surprised to find no association between medications and falls in either univariate or multivariate analyses. We believe that this may be related to the high number of medications taken by all HD patients. Only four of 162 patients were taking fewer than four medications, and most were taking seven to 12 medications. This result is in contrast to that of Desmet et al. (15), who, in a younger, relatively healthy dialysis population, found that age, diabetes, medications (especially antidepressants), and ambulatory aid requirement were predictive of falls.
For the clinical nephrologist who is caring for older patients treated with chronic outpatient dialysis, fall risk should be considered as important as other concurrent issues, such as anemia management and bone mineral metabolism. Falls are well recognized as precursors to fractures, increased functional disability, and the need for long-term institutional care (5,9,10,13). Falling is a marker of frailty, and fall prevention is a key to reducing poor outcomes. Therefore, nephrologists can play an instrumental role in identifying those who are at high risk for falls and referring these individuals to multidisciplinary falls assessment clinics (grade A recommendation [46]) and fall prevention programs. Recognition of patients who recall having fallen in the past year could be used to trigger evaluation of fall risk. This could help to minimize the morbidity and possibly the mortality that are associated with recurrent falls and in turn improve the quality of life of the patients, reduce the burden on family and health care caregivers, and potentially reduce institutionalization. Although there are many effective interventions for falls (14,4751) none has been studied in dialysis populations.
| Conclusion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
This article was presented in abstract and poster form at the annual meeting of the American Society of Nephrology; November 8 through 13, 2005; Philadelphia, PA.
We thank the patients and staff who participated in this project, in particular Dimitra Jovanovich for diligent and thorough work.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received May 12, 2006. Accepted June 25, 2006.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
E. L. Hartmann, D. Kitzman, M. Rocco, X. Leng, H. Klepin, M. Gordon, J. Rejeski, M. Berry, and S. Kritchevsky Physical Function in Older Candidates for Renal Transplantation: An Impaired Population Clin. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol., March 1, 2009; 4(3): 588 - 594. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Li, G. Tomlinson, G. Naglie, W. L Cook, and S. V. Jassal Geriatric comorbidities, such as falls, confer an independent mortality risk to elderly dialysis patients Nephrol. Dial. Transplant., April 1, 2008; 23(4): 1396 - 1400. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Jadoul Towards the prevention of bone fractures in dialysed patients? Nephrol. Dial. Transplant., December 1, 2007; 22(12): 3377 - 3380. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |